1973 RSR Cars for sale

[911MRP]

I don’t know the details so can only take the article on face value but back in 2019 this newspaper article suggested there was a legal dispute looming:
https://rennlist.com/articles/two-id...-off-in-court/

I don’t have access to papers posted on the link below. Seems like some updates this month? Might this information be related to the legal case previously reported in the NY newspaper article ?
https://www.pacermonitor.com/public/...it_v_Schachter

[HughH]

Steve
I am not going to create an account to read the PDF's either
However I am certain it is related to that case and it seems to me, from reading what i can see there, that Jacob Shalit (who has the car he says came ex Mexico and was the one referenced in Starkey's book as "the car" as it has been known and around for much longer - I saw it in person in 2007) was looking to bring the case forward but that was rejected by the Judge.
But is does not look to me (in the absence of seeing those documents) that it is the end of the case of which car (if either) is the "correct" car.

With all the apparently fraudulent cars around now courtesy of groups such as the one on trial in Germany and others, it would be good to see some judicial ruling on this matter - however whether a court can get it "right" remains to be seen and honestly I am not hopeful

[SKM]

It appears the parties reached a settlement agreement however the details of such agreement are not available to the public.

Still displayed on Schachter's website.

https://www.rovecars.com/portfolio-i...-prototype-r7/

Many court reporting sites list the case docket. Not sure if any show the actual settlement agreement.

https://www.courtlistener.com/docket...t-v-schachter/

Case 1:19-cv-05971-NRB Document 97 Filed 05/23/23
Page 1 of 2
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
-------------------------------------X
JACOB SHALIT,
Plaintiff, - against –
KENNY SCHACHTER and ILONA RICH,
Defendants.
-------------------------------------X
NAOMI REICE BUCHWALD
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
ORDER
19 Civ. 5971 (NRB)
WHEREAS, on May 22, 2023, the parties informed this Court that they have reached a settlement in principle;
WHEREAS, at an in-person conference on May 23, 2023, the parties entered the broad terms of their settlement agreement on the record;
WHEREAS the parties agreed that if the terms of the settlement agreement are not fully performed, plaintiff may file an application to restore this action or move to enforce the settlement agreement by February 29, 2024; it is hereby
ORDERED that the above-captioned action be, and hereby is, dismissed without costs and without prejudice to restoring the action to this Court’s calendar if the application to restore the action is made by February 29, 2024.
DATED:
New York, New York
May 23, 2023
Case 1:19-cv-05971-NRB Document 97 Filed 05/23/23 Page 2 of 2
_
_______
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
N
A
D
_
_
_
_
O
O
M
_
M
_
_
I
R
I
R
_
_
_
_
_
_
E
E
_
_
I
I
C
_
_
C
_
_
_
E
B
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

[alarson11]

[QUOTE=DOUGS73E;1154132]The Six Auction - Vente Aux Encheres Speciale Agrasc, Balsan Enchères, Cherre, France, June 29, 2023
1973 Porsche 2.8L 911 Carrera RSR
VIN: 9113601033
Engine: 6930155
Trans: -
Color: White/Black
Mileage:
Auction Estimate: 1 000 000 - 2 000 000 EUR
Sold for: TBD

Attachment 597264

Can anyone share the results from this auction on this and the other cars offered?

[NG62]

Here you go
https://www.glenmarch.com/auctions/results/2134

[DOUGS73E]

February 2023 - Artcurial Salon Rétromobile Auction - NO SALE
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The Six Auction - Vente Aux Encheres Speciale Agrasc, Balsan Enchères, Cherre, France, June 29, 2023
1971 Porsche 911 S/T Rally 2,3L
VIN: 9111301270
Engine: 6318011
Trans: -
Color: Irish Green/Black
Mileage: 92,128 km (indicated)
Auction Estimate: €500,000 - €1,000,000
Sold for: €537,116 / ~US$589,460

1971 Porsche 2.3L 911ST 1270 - Conda Green 1.jpg

1971 Porsche 2.3L 911ST 1270 - Irish Green 2.jpg

1971 Porsche 2.3L 911ST 1270 - Irish Green 3.jpg

1971 Porsche 2.3L 911ST 1270 - Irish Green 4.jpg

[Leirbag]

February 2023 - Bonhams Goodwood Revival Auction
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Goodwood Revival Auction - 9-10 september 2023
1973 Martini-Porsche 911 Carrera 3.0 RSR Works Prototype (R7)
VIN: 9113600686
Engine: -
Trans: -
Color: Martini
Mileage: -
Auction Estimate: -
Sold for: -


image (1).jpg
image (2).jpg
image.jpg
1973-rsr-prototype-r7-06-full.jpg

[SKM]

September Sports Car Market Legal Files column discusses 9113600686 and the lawsuit associated with it. Worth reading.

[911MRP]

Any chance of a précis here for those who don’t subscribe?

[911MRP]

In the absence of anyone with subscription providing a précis the auction listing in link above does have a few comments regarding the reported legal case and recent outcome:

“Upon completion of its Martini Porsche works team season, 'R7' was sold to Mexican Porsche exponent Hector Rebaque for use in national racing back home. After competing successfully there in 'Viceroy' cigarette-brand colours, it was sold into the discreet long-term ownership of Italian enthusiast collector Massimo Baliva. In part due to the car's disappearance from the scene – Baliva essentially keeping his stewardship of the car very much to himself – some elements within the classic Porsche world assumed its destruction. As, is often the case a replica was constructed and when Massimo Baliva's car emerged from obscurity (he was selling his collection due to his advanced age) litigation ensued. The case was ordered dismissed and the case settled, with the replica car being acknowledged as such.

The present car offered by Bonhams|Cars' authenticity had been confirmed by legendary Porsche engineer Norbert Singer (1973 Martini Porsche team manager) whose forensically detailed examination proved it indeed to be the original 1973 RSR team car 'R7'.”


The link to the Bonhams listing is reposted here so the extract above can be read in context https://www.bonhams.com/press_release/36827/