Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 29

Thread: New purchase dilemma....newer Porsche or vintage BMW

  1. #1

    New purchase dilemma....newer Porsche or vintage BMW

    Dumb question....I know these two cars are like comparing 'apples and oranges' but I'm attracted to both for different reasons. I'm considering which one would be a better purchase and I'm looking for advise. The two cars in question are a 1968 BMW 2002 or a 2000 Porsche Boxster S. The 2002 would sit adjacent to my '74 914 2.0L in the garage and would be used occasionally for nice weather weekend drives while the Boxtser would probably be used more often.....but not as a daily driver. Both cars are in excellent condition.....the 2002 is in mint driver condition while the Boxster is concours with only 8K miles and had the IMS bearing replaced already. The 2002 is more $$$ than the Boxster but would probably retain it's value better in the longer term. I'm very open to hearing anyone's experience with these two cars and any advise / suggestions.

    Please feel free to move this thread if it's in the wrong forum.

    Thanks
    Attached Images Attached Images
    JEFF BRINTON
    ESR #1572
    1968 911N
    1974 914 2.0L
    2023 Macan
    SOLD - 1967 911N / 1968 911L / 1967 911N / 1969 912 / 1991 964 C2 / 2013 991.1 / 2008 987 Cayman

  2. #2
    Senior Member Scott A's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    South East USA
    Posts
    897
    i think I would chose the 2002, it gives you something to talk about, work on and learn about.
    the boxster has too much plastic, and you can hardly change the oil, so nothing to learn, or even talk about.

    Current long term ownership: 63 Cab, 71 911, 74 914

  3. #3
    Oil Cooled Heart Bullethead's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    South Florida
    Posts
    2,195
    You've already acknowledged your economic choice: though it will cost more initially, the 2002 will probably always be worth more than what you pay for it.

    Plus, they're simple mechanically, don't cost the world to service, and are fun to drive.
    Russ

    ESR # 1537

    '62 356S Notchback Hotrod
    '67 S Das Geburtstagsgeschenk
    '68 T Targa Sportomatic
    '68 L SW Targa Sportomatic
    '70 914/6 GT

  4. #4
    Boxster = Ughh

    Do the 2002.

  5. #5
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Location
    UK
    Posts
    2,720
    For about four years I used to spend many a happy day or two each week hanging out and helping out possibly the most respected and most loved UK Porsche specialist in the UK who'd owned his independent Porsche business since 74. The surest way to spoil my dear pal's day and ensure non-stop grumbling / muttered disapproval was for a customer to bring in a Boxster to his workshop. Miss him enormously since he passed away -- except of course on those bad mood "cos Boxter was on his ramp" days

    Nuff said !

    Steve

  6. #6
    Senior Member bob joyce's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2017
    Location
    el sobrante ca.
    Posts
    1,151
    I have a 2005 Boxster S... I love it .. if you appreciate modern Porsche technology you will get it for a very affordable price. but I have to say, those boxy BMW cars do nothing for me. I don't see how an older BMW would be cheaper to upkeep than the Porsche. as far appreciation I know I would appreciate the Boxster on a nice summer drive.... as to weather the BMW would be worth more money in 5 or 10 years I would care less...

  7. #7
    Senior Member uai's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Location
    Horb a.N. Germany
    Posts
    2,556
    I need more pics of the 2002. It definetely has some rare original features that are lost on most cars. It is bristol ?
    If the BMW is as as good as it seems from the one pic I'd go for it.
    In your case I'd suggest driving it - if it pleases you go for it- if you feel the urge for more power you're willing to spend ca. 20k$ + work on the bmw you can build a nice sleeper period correct hot rod with good handlig, good brakes, 170-180 hp on 98 octane, 5spd and all is reversible in case you want to go back.
    If it's about speed and deprecation get a Z3M coupe or even a Z4M coupe or a Cayman S ?

  8. #8
    Senior Member TurkisTii's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Location
    Chicago, IL
    Posts
    138
    I can help you justify getting both cars. I've got a 99 M Roadster which was one of the three cars the car magazines had shootouts with the Boxster and S2000. As you said comparing apples to oranges. I've gotten more enjoyment tinkering with my 2002tii and the driving experience. Adding the 911 this past spring has only renewed my interest completing projects I have with 2002 and taking it to various events. Just make sure you get what you really want in regards to color and condition.

    IMG_20190707_064516.jpg
    Early 911S Registry #3811
    '70 911S Coupe Tangerine
    Instagram @turkis.tii

  9. #9
    Thanks for the feedback and comments. I guess I'm leaning towards to the BMW.....the Boxster's are a 'dime-a-dozen' so I could always purchase one down the road if I desired. The Boxster is a drive anywhere, any distance, any time type of a car. While the BMW is the fun, occasional driver that would be nice compliment to my 914.
    Here are some additional photos of the BMW @uai.
    Attached Images Attached Images
    JEFF BRINTON
    ESR #1572
    1968 911N
    1974 914 2.0L
    2023 Macan
    SOLD - 1967 911N / 1968 911L / 1967 911N / 1969 912 / 1991 964 C2 / 2013 991.1 / 2008 987 Cayman

  10. #10
    That 2002 is non-matching engine, correct? Guess have to figure that it in (right or wrong...) if you look to sell down the road.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Message Board Disclaimer and Terms of Use
This is a public forum. Messages posted here can be viewed by the public. The Early 911S Registry is not responsible for messages posted in its online forums, and any message will express the views of the author and not the Early 911S Registry. Use of online forums shall constitute the agreement of the user not to post anything of religious or political content, false and defamatory, inaccurate, abusive, vulgar, hateful, harassing, obscene, profane, sexually oriented, threatening, invasive of a person's privacy, or otherwise to violate the law and the further agreement of the user to be solely responsible for and hold the Early 911S Registry harmless in the event of any claim based on their message. Any viewer who finds a message objectionable should contact us immediately by email. The Early 911S Registry has the ability to remove objectionable messages and we will make every effort to do so, within a reasonable time frame, if we determine that removal is necessary.