A Scheel Replica is quite easy to do fairly correct looking. Recaro repops are always bad as no one seems to be able to replicate the gelcoat surface. For me (I have both originals) it‘s the Recaro. It just fits my butt better apart from being really solid compared to old flimsy Scheel stuff.
I‘d bite the bullet and go for original Recaro, if that is not an option then replica Scheel would be my choice. Gerrit is no longer active but there are still some of his repops floating around. Perhaps alex still has some (aasink ) here on the forum.